Acta Scientific Dental Sciences (ASDS)(ISSN: 2581-4893)

Research Article Volume 6 Issue 3

Efficacy of Two Rotary Systems Versus Manual Instrumentation During Retreatment: An In Vitro Study

Brijila Kuriakose1* and Rahul Maria2

1Post Graduate Student Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics, Bhabha College of Dental Sciences, India
2Professor and Head of the Department, Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics, Bhabha College of Dental Sciences, India

*Corresponding Author: Brijila Kuriakose, Post Graduate Student Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics, Bhabha College of Dental Sciences, India.

Received: February 07, 2022; Published: February 24, 2022


Aim:The aim of this study is to evaluate the cleaning efficiency of two rotary retreatment instrumentation techniques and Hand instrumentation technique (H file with solvent) in removing obturating material from the root canal walls, during retreatment procedure using scanning electron microscope.

Material and Methodology: A total of 45 human mandibular Premolar teeth with straight root canals were selected and the coronal one third enlarged with one flare. The biomechananical preparation of the teeth were done till F1 size ProTaper universal rotary file and gutta-percha and AH Plus sealer is used for obturation performed by lateral condensation technique. The samples were divided into three groups according to the retreatment system Group I- H File with solvent, Group II- ProTaper universal retreatment file system and Group III-WaveOne gold primary File. For the evaluation of residual materials, the buccolingually sectioned tooth samples were observed under scanning electron microscope. The statistical analysis of the data was obtained using one way ANOVA and Independent t- test.

Result: The highest amount of remaining filling materials was observed in the apical third followed by middle third and coronal third. WaveOne Gold primary file which works in reciprocating motion showed superior cleaning efficiency than ProTaper universal rotary system which works in continous motion and manual H file with solvent.

Conclusion: None of the system was able to remove obturating material completely. The efficiency of reciprocating files shown to be superior in removing the filling material compared to continuous retreatment system. The least cleaning efficiency is exhibited by H file with solvent group in removal of root canal filling material.

Keywords: Retreatment; Filling Materials; Gutta-Percha; H File; ProTaper; Rotary System


  1. PK Thaku Raj., et al. “Evaluation of effectiveness of two different Endodontic Retreatment systems in removal of gutta percha: An invitro study”. Journal of Contemporary Dentistry 6 (2018): 726-731.
  2. Saad AY., et al. “Efficacy of two rotary NiTi instruments in the removal of gutta-percha during root canal retreatment”. The Journal of Endodontics 33 (2007) :38-41.
  3. Giuliani V., et al. “Efficacy of ProTaper universal retreatment files in removing filling materials during root canal retreatment”. The Journal of Endodontics 11 (2008) 1381-1384.
  4. Farzaneh M., et al. “Treatment outcome in endodontics: the Toronto study-phases I and II: orthograde retreatment”. The Journal of Endodontics 30 (2004): 627-633.
  5. Stabholz A., et al. “Endodontic retreatment: case selection and technique. Part2: treatment planning for retreatment”. The Journal of Endodontics 12 (1988): 607-614.
  6. Unal C., et al. “A comparison of the efficacy of conventional and new retreatment instruments to remove gutta-percha in curved root canals: an ex vivo study”. International Endodontic Journal 42 (2009): 344-350.
  7. Hasija MK., et al. “Evaluation of Gutta-Percha Removal from the Dentinal Tubules Using Different Instrumentation Techniques with or Without Solvent: An In vitro Study”. Journal of the International Clinical Dental Research 12 (2020): 27-32.
  8. Schwerz L., et al. “Comparison of the effectiveness of the protaper system versus hand instrumentation in endodontic retreatment: a scanning electron microscopy study”. RSBO Le Réseau de Recherche en Santé Buccodentaire et Osseuse4 (2012); 368-374.
  9. RA Bernardes., et al. “Comparison of three retreatment techniques with ultrasonic activation in flattened canals using micro-computed tomography and scanning electron microscopy”. International Endodontic Journal 9 (2016): 890-897.
  10. Pirani C., et al. “Effectiveness of Three Different Retreatment Techniques in Canals Filled with Compacted Gutta-Percha or Thermafil: A Scanning Electron Microscope Study”. The Journal of Endodontics 10 (2009): 1433-1440.
  11. Nouri H., et al. “Comparison of full rotation and reciprocating movements in regaining apical patency during endodontic retreatment”. Journal of Dental Research 18 (2021): 85.
  12. Akbulut MB., et al. “Efficacy of Twisted File Adaptive, Reciproc and ProTaper Universal Retreatment instruments for root-canal-filling removal: A cone-beam computed tomography study”. Dental Materials Journal 1 (2016): 126-131.
  13. Keskin C., et al. “Efficacy of novel thermomechanically treated reciprocating systems for gutta-percha removal from root canals obturated with warm vertical compaction”. Journal of Dental Research, Dental Clinics, Dental Prospects 2 (2018): 110-115.
  14. Mărușter R., et al. “The Efficacy of Waveone Gold and Mtwo retreatment files in the removal of carrier-based gutta-percha obturators”. Journal of Oral Rehabilitation 3 (2020): 55-63.
  15. Fatima K., et al. “Efficacy of rotary and reciprocating single-file systems on different access outlines for gutta-percha removal in retreatment: An in vitro study”. Journal of Conservative Dentistry 21 (2018): 354-358.
  16. Meyappan R., et al. “Effectiveness of Conventional and three different Rotary Retreatment techniques in canals obturated with Gutta Percha: A Scanning Electron Microscopic Study”. Endodontology2 (2014): 259-265.
  17. Fariniuk LF., et al. “Efficacy of Five Rotary Systems versus Manual Instrumentation During Endodontic Retreatment”. Brazilian Dental Journal J4 (2011): 294-298.
  18. Kasam S., et al. “Efficacy of Different Methods for Removing Root Canal Filling Material in Retreatment - An In-vitro Study”. Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research 6 (2016): ZC06-ZC10.
  19. SD Horvath., et al. “Cleanliness of dentinal tubules following gutta-percha removal with and without solvents: a scanning electron microscopic study”. International Endodontic Journal 42 (2009): 1032-1038.
  20. Al-Obaidi MA., et al. “Comparison of the Effectiveness of Reciprocating System with Continuous Rotary Systems in Non-Surgical Endodontic Retreatment (An In vitro study)”. Journal of Baghdad College of Dentistry 1 (2016): 57-62.
  21. Nawaf RN., et al. “Retreatment Efficacy of Continuous Rotation Versus Reciprocation Kinematic Movements in Removing Gutta-Percha with Calcium Silicate-Based Sealer: SEM Study”. Journal of Research in Medical and Dental Science 5 (2021): 80-87.
  22. Gu LS and Ling JQ. “Efficacy of ProTaper Universal rotary retreatment system for gutta-percha removal from root canals”. International Endodontic Journal 4 (2008): 288-295.
  23. Silva EJN., et al. “Effectiveness of rotatory and reciprocating movements in root canal filling material removal”. Brazilian Oral Research 1 (2015): 1-6.
  24. Schirrmeister J., et al. “Effectiveness of a hand file and three nickel-titanium rotary instruments for removing gutta-percha in curved root canals during retreatment”. Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, and Oral Radiology Endodontic 101 (2006): 542-547.


Citation: Brijila Kuriakose and Rahul Maria. “Efficacy of Two Rotary Systems Versus Manual Instrumentation During Retreatment: An In Vitro Study". Acta Scientific Dental Sciences 6.3 (2022): 73-80.


Copyright: © 2022 Brijila Kuriakose and Rahul Maria. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.


Acceptance rate30%
Acceptance to publication20-30 days
Impact Factor1.278

Indexed In

News and Events

  • Certification for Review
    Acta Scientific certifies the Editors/reviewers for their review done towards the assigned articles of the respective journals.
  • Submission Timeline for Upcoming Issue
    The last date for submission of articles for regular Issues is April 30th, 2024.
  • Publication Certificate
    Authors will be issued a "Publication Certificate" as a mark of appreciation for publishing their work.
  • Best Article of the Issue
    The Editors will elect one Best Article after each issue release. The authors of this article will be provided with a certificate of "Best Article of the Issue".
  • Welcoming Article Submission
    Acta Scientific delightfully welcomes active researchers for submission of articles towards the upcoming issue of respective journals.

Contact US